Would You be Insulted if Asked These Interview Questions?

For Parents Safety: Questions for Prospective Nannies by Gavin de Becker

After the killing of an eight-year old boy in Brooklyn this month, we have been sharing advice by notable security and safety expert Gavin de Becker. Today he tries to help parents screen caregivers before hiring nannies to work in their home.

In our culture of short encounters and little accountability, it is important to learn a lot about someone you bring into your life, particularly someone who’ll be alone with your children. The more you know about someone, the more you reduce that person’s anonymity. If you have talked to five of the candidate’s references, that’s five more inhibitors against bad conduct, five people whom you and the babysitter know in common, five people who could hear about a misdeed. When you have many inroads into a person’s life, you raise the consequences for bad behavior.

Pre-employment questions are low-tech, easy tests you can perform when screening someone to take care of your kids. They are designed not just to elicit information, but to put important subjects on the agenda.

Among the questions you might ask (after having someone fill out an application):

1. What is your philosophy about discipline?
Exploring this topic will reveal their opinions, and also serve as an ideal segue for you to set forth your house rules on discipline. If you don’t want the babysitter spanking your child, this is the time to say so.

2. Have you ever suspected that a child in your care was being sexually molested by someone?
This question is designed as a bridge into the topic of sexual abuse, but also as a way to test denial, and you do not want a denier as a babysitter or nanny. People caring for children have a duty to acknowledge and recognize reality, even hard reality, and denial is an evasion of that duty. When evaluating a babysitter, put sexual crimes against children squarely on the agenda. If the person you are talking with is a denier, you’ll know it quickly (“Things like that don’t happen around here;” ‘”I’ve never even considered such a thing;” “I’ve only worked with good families,” etc.).

3. Do you have children of your own? Do you have younger siblings?
It may be a plus when they answer yes to either question. In any event, the topic allows easy transition to several other areas: Did you take care of siblings when you were growing up? How old were you when you first stayed with them alone? How young do you think is too young?

4. Why do you do this work?
The answer might be ‘‘For the money,’’ ‘‘It allows me time to study/read,’’ ‘‘I love children,’’ ‘‘It’s easy,’’ or ‘‘I dunno,’’ but whatever it is, the answer will inform your intuition.

5. Have you ever been in an emergency situation while babysitting? Have you ever been in any emergency situation?
These questions can reveal the applicant’s thought processes about emergencies.

6. What is your opinion of drugs and alcohol?
Many parents look intently at applicants, hoping somehow to determine if they are drug or alcohol abusers. There’s a greater likelihood of learning something valuable about the topic by discussing it explicitly.

7. Describe a problem you had in your life where someone else’s help was very important to you.
Is the applicant able to recall such a situation? If so, does he or she give credit or express appreciation about the help? A candidate who is not willing to accept help might not be the best caretaker for your child.

8. Who is your best friend and how would you describe your friendship?
While many people will name several friends, there are, believe it or not, some who cannot think of a single person. Another benefit to the question comes if an applicant gives a name that was not listed as a reference (which happens often). Ask why the person wasn’t listed; ask if you can now have the contact number.

9. Describe the best child you ever babysat for. Describe the worst child you ever babysat for.
This is a powerful inquiry that can reveal important attitudes about children and behavior. If the applicant speaks for just a moment about the best child, but can wax on enthusiastically about the worst, this is telling. Does he or she use unkind expressions to explain the trouble with a given child (’‘brat,’‘ ‘‘little monster’‘)? Does the applicant take any responsibility for his or her part?

A follow-up is: Could you have taken another approach?

Other questions might include:

  • Can you give me some examples of problems you have had with kids and how you handled them?
  • What if my son fails to obey you when you ask him to do something?
  • What if he is doing something dangerous?
  • How do you handle fighting between brothers and sisters?
  • How do you handle tantrums?
  • How would you react if a child bit or hit you?
  • What do you do when you become angry with a child?
  • What if my daughter asked you to keep a secret? What would your response be?
  • What if she revealed something to you that you knew I wouldn’t approve of?
  • Can you swim? Would you be willing to go in the pool with our child?
  • At what point would you call a pediatrician or 911?
  • Do you prefer to work with boys or girls and why?
  • What would you do if you saw a child fondling himself or herself?
  • How would you handle a situation of this nature?

During your interview, few things are as powerful as silence. When someone finishes an answer you consider incomplete, don’t just accept it and go on. Instead, wait silently; he or she will start talking again and give you more information to evaluate.

Some parents ask about medical conditions that could be relevant, and some even ask babysitters to pass medical examinations or drug-screen tests. Some require special skills, such as CPR. (Remember that CPR for infants requires training beyond regular CPR.) Safe Sitter is an excellent national program that teaches an intensive two-day course in the prevention and management of accidents. Founded by Dr. Patricia Keener, Safe Sitter (1-800-255-4089) teaches babysitters (as young as eleven-years-old) about medical emergencies in addition to the basics of childcare. Student must pass a rigorous written and practical exam.


  1. I am not insulted by any question except if it has to do with my sexual life or religion. Even religion doesn't bother me much. I am an open book!

  2. Because I have been in some tough jobs like messy divorces, working for widowers (where religion can play a part in how the family copes), and been in homes where a parent has had an addiction, I think there are very few questions that phase me any more. And because I have answered them previously because they pertain to a certain job, and I got why it was asked then, I don't think any would make me pause.

  3. I am a professional, working black woman and used Craigslist as a supplement to the agencies that I was using. One of the first non agency interviews I scheduled at my home involved a Jamaican woman. When I opened the door, she said abruptly, "Oh I didn't know you were the black". I asked her if that was a problem and she assured me that it wasn't, but clearly it was.

  4. I wouldn't be insulted by these questions. Only red flag I ever had was a father yelling at employees on the phone during our interview. I declined the job.

  5. I would not be insulted to answer any questionHowever if I choose to not answer somethingthat is my right I would be professional and say I chose to not answer that question because I feel it is inapprociate or way to personal.

  6. I wouldn't feel insulted with these questions since the parents are inviting us into their homes. But I was asked if I had peircings once and I have peirced ears and was surprised anyone would ask that.

  7. I had my profile on all the nanny sites. They clearly stated my salary expectations. A family with four children notifies me, and we talk about the job over the phone. I asked about salary and they said my requirements were fine. They lived over thirty miles away so it was quite a drive to go meet with them. After half day interview found out they were offering $300 less than I was asking.

  8. They asked if they could do a credit check on me. Since I am not an accountant, no. I won't be working with their money or writing their checks. Don't see how it applies to a nanny.

  9. I was asked if I ever brought a law suit against another employer!!?!Um no, obviously you did… I ran for the hills… LOL

  10. I would not mind these questions. However I have been asked some crazy questions by agencies. The worst was- does anyone in your family have a drinking problem?and what do your parents do for a living?

  11. The worst interview for me was the mom and dad were both wearing bluetooth earpieces and kept having to step out of the interview. I heard the dad yelling at someone while he took one of the calls and I knew I couldn't work for him.

  12. These interview questions are completely appropriate. But I was asked if I had a boyfriend and if we had sex. I just laughed and didn't answer the question. WTF?! I knew I wouldn't be working for them!

  13. My worst nanny job interview was with the Grandmother instead of the parents! The mother was "napping" when I started the interview with the Grandmother!! Near the end of the interview the mom came down and seemed disinterested. She yawned while I was talking and never asked one question! It was too weird I declined the job offer by lying and saying I had accepted another job.

  14. RE: the sex question; I'm assuming parents ask because they want to know what values you'll be teaching their kids and if you share their religious views. But there are polite ways to ask about your morals and values and how much of that you share with the kids you take care of without being so awkward! Parents are so clueless sometimes.I think the worst thing I've been asked is if I minded only taking all of my paid vacation when they took vacation, because they went away for several weeks a year without a nanny. I was like, um, no… I have friends and family who have weddings, funerals, etc. as well. I do need SOME say in my time off because hello, I'm a person with a life.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: